Row of vintage analog alarm clocks on a shelf closest clock showing roughly 1200
|

You Be The Tax Judge: Can The IRS Go Back Dozens of Years To Assess Taxes?

The IRS generally has three years to assess additional taxes after you file your federal income tax return. But what happens when the IRS discovers fraud decades later—and the taxpayer had nothing to do with it?

That’s the question in this week’s You Be The Tax Judge.

The Facts

For tax years 1993 through 1999, Stephanie Murrin and her then-husband hired professional tax preparer Duane Howell to prepare their federal income tax returns.

The couple relied on Howell to prepare their returns, which were filed on time. There was just one problem: Howell was putting false information on the returns. Howell included fraudulent entries on their individual returns and on returns for two partnerships in which Murrin was a general partner. His goal was to evade taxes.

The Murrins didn’t make the false entries themselves. They didn’t know about the fraud, and they didn’t intend to evade taxes.

In 2019, the IRS issued a notice of deficiency for the couple’s 1993 through 1999 tax years. That meant the IRS was seeking additional taxes on returns filed roughly two decades earlier. With penalties and an estimated $250,000 in interest, the total bill had grown to more than $328,000.

Murrin didn’t dispute that the returns understated the taxes owed. She agreed that the underlying tax deficiencies totaled $65,318, plus $13,064 in accuracy-related penalties.

But she challenged the IRS on one important point: Wasn’t it too late to assess those taxes?

What Does The Law Say?

Under section 6501(a) of the tax code, the IRS generally has three years after a return is filed to assess additional tax. This is known as the statute of limitations on assessment.

The rule provides taxpayers with some certainty. Once the assessment period expires, the IRS generally can’t come back years later and assess additional tax for that return.

But there are exceptions. One exception appears in section 6501(c)(1). It says that when a return is false or fraudulent with the intent to evade tax, the IRS can assess tax at any time. In other words, when the fraud exception applies, there is no ordinary three-year deadline for assessing tax.

Murrin argued that the fraud exception shouldn’t apply to her because she didn’t intend to evade taxes. Her tax preparer placed the fraudulent information on the returns without her knowledge.

The IRS disagreed. The IRS argued that the statute focuses on whether the return was fraudulent, not necessarily whether the taxpayer intended to commit fraud.

Under the IRS’s interpretation, a taxpayer could face additional tax assessments decades after filing a return—even when someone else committed the fraud. Under Murrin’s interpretation, the fraud exception would apply only when the taxpayer had the requisite fraudulent intent.

You Be The Tax Judge

The facts weren’t really in dispute. The parties agreed that the preparer committed fraud and that Murrin did not intend to evade taxes. The question was whether the IRS could still assess additional taxes after the normal three-year assessment period had expired.

You be the tax judge. Who wins?

  • The taxpayer wins. The fraud exception requires the taxpayer to have fraudulent intent. Because Murrin didn’t intend to evade taxes, the IRS missed its deadline.
  • The IRS wins. The fraud exception applies to a fraudulent return, even when the fraudulent intent belongs to the preparer rather than the taxpayer. The assessment period remains open.
  • It depends.

Vote below. I’ll share how the court ruled—and why—in next week’s follow-up.

Who should win?

View Results

Loading ...
Facebooktwitterlinkedinmail

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.