You Be The Tax Judge: The $9.6 Million Lottery Tax Ruling
Last week, I asked you to serve as a tax judge in a dispute involving a Pennsylvania couple who won nearly $9.6 million in the lottery and sold their rights to future payments, resulting in a substantial tax bill.
The question was whether the proceeds from selling those payment rights should be taxed as long-term capital gains, ordinary income, or something else. So, what was the answer?
It was ordinary income. And 62% of you agreed.
Background
Here’s a quick recap of the facts. In 1991, George and Angeline Lattera won $9,595,326 in the Pennsylvania Lottery. Under the rules at the time, they couldn’t collect their winnings in one lump sum. Instead, they were entitled to 26 annual payments of $369,051.
In 1999, the couple sold their rights to the remaining 17 payments for $3,372,342. On their federal income tax return, they reported the proceeds as a long-term capital gain, reporting a zero basis.
The IRS disagreed, treating the money as ordinary income and issuing a notice of deficiency for $660,784.
The Latteras challenged the determination in Tax Court, arguing that they’d sold a capital asset they had held for more than a year.
The Tax Court sided with the IRS. The Latteras appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit.
What Did The Court Decide?
In Lattera v. Commissioner, 437 F.3d 399 (3d Cir. 2006), the Third Circuit affirmed the Tax Court’s decision. The court held that the money the Latteras received for selling their future lottery payments was taxable as ordinary income, not capital gains.
The key was a longstanding principle known as the substitute-for-ordinary-income doctrine. Under that doctrine, receiving a lump sum in exchange for income that would otherwise be taxable as ordinary income doesn’t magically transform that money into a capital gain.
In other words, if you’re entitled to receive ordinary income over several years, selling your right to collect that income doesn’t change its tax character. You may have changed when and how you receive the money, but you haven’t changed what the money represents. That’s what the IRS argued happened here.
The Latteras weren’t selling a traditional investment like stock or real estate. They were selling their right to collect lottery winnings that were already owed to them.
But Wasn’t It Still A Sale?
Yes. And that’s what makes it interesting.
The Latteras legally transferred their rights to all 17 remaining payments, and they received money from a third party in exchange for those rights. Typically, selling a capital asset held for more than one year results in a long-term capital gain if the sale produces a gain. But the Third Circuit explained that not everything that qualifies as property in the ordinary sense necessarily receives capital gains treatment.
The court also acknowledged that the substitute-for-ordinary-income doctrine can be tricky. After all, many capital assets (like real estate) derive their value from income they might generate in the future. A stock, for example, may be valuable because of anticipated profits and dividends. But that doesn’t mean selling stock automatically produces ordinary income.
So where should courts draw the line?
The Difference Between Earning Income And Collecting It
The Third Circuit developed what it called a “family resemblance” test to help distinguish
capital assets from rights to ordinary income.
For transactions that didn’t clearly fall into either category, the court considered whether the seller gave up all or only part of an interest, then examined the nature of the rights being sold.
Here, the Latteras had sold all their remaining lottery payments, which could have supported their argument that they’d disposed of an asset rather than merely assigned part of a future income stream.
But that wasn’t the end of the analysis. The court distinguished between two concepts:
- The right to earn income: An asset or right that requires something more to generate income in the future.
- The right to earned income: A right to receive money already earned, even if payment won’t arrive until later.
That -ed is doing a lot of heavy lifting. And the Latteras fell into the second category. They had already won the lottery. They didn’t need to do anything else to earn their winnings. Selling the right to collect the payments didn’t turn them into a capital gain.
Why Does It Matter?
Money. The distinction between ordinary income and capital gains can significantly impact your federal income tax liability.
Long-term capital gains generally receive preferential tax rates (0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on your tax rate). Ordinary income is subject to the regular graduated income tax brackets (10%, 12%, 22%, 24%, 32%, 35%, and 37% for 2026 and 2027). You can see what those brackets look like for 2027 here.
But simply holding something for more than a year, or legally transferring it to someone else, doesn’t guarantee capital gains treatment. What matters is what you’re selling.
The Final Ruling
On February 14, 2006, the Third Circuit affirmed the Tax Court’s decision, holding that the proceeds from the sale of the Latteras’ future lottery payments were ordinary income. That means that the IRS won.
The takeaway? You can’t necessarily change the character of income simply by selling the right to receive it. That’s true whether you’re dealing with lottery winnings or some other capital asset.
Ironically, the Latteras may have won their prize a little too early. In 1996, Pennsylvania changed its lottery law to allow players in certain games to choose a lump-sum payout instead of annual installments. Although Pennsylvania Lottery winnings had long been subject to federal income tax, the Commonwealth didn’t begin taxing those cash prizes at the state level until 2016. That year, Pennsylvania also introduced mandatory state income tax withholding on qualifying lottery payments exceeding $5,000.
And the change wasn’t limited to new winners: Annuity payments received in 2016 or later were subject to Pennsylvania income tax even if the winning ticket had been purchased years earlier.


